Listeria Risk in Smoked Fish: A Balanced Perspective

The UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) has recently brought attention to a potential health concern for certain groups of individuals who regularly consume smoked fish. The consumption of such fish may elevate the risk of contracting an illness caused by the bacterium Listeria monocytogenes, better known as listeriosis. Particularly vulnerable groups include the elderly, pregnant individuals, and those with compromised immune systems.

---

How has the UKHSA arrived at this conclusion?

The UKHSA conducts detailed studies on patterns of foodborne illness outbreaks and tests various food categories to trace the source of harmful bacteria. Their research, incorporating the most up-to-date global data, has found an increasing correlation between the consumption of smoked fish in the UK and the incidence of listeriosis. This link has been under the spotlight since 2015, with the advent of a new bacteria identification method known as whole genome sequencing. 

In the years since 2015, there has been a surge in cases connected to the intake of smoked fish, particularly from 2020 onwards. Notably, the UKHSA discovered a substantial hike in the probability of locating the Listeria bacteria in smoked salmon samples. This issue isn't confined to the UK alone; there have been numerous outbreaks worldwide connected to smoked fish in the recent past. Consequently, there is a growing recognition of smoked fish as a high-risk food category for Listeria contamination.

---

Where does Think Through Nutrition stand on this?

While we at Think Through Nutrition acknowledge the legitimate concerns surrounding listeriosis, we want to emphasise that not all oily fish should be implicated in this problem. The potential risk is specifically linked to smoked fish variants, meaning that regular, non-smoked oily fish should not be categorised as high risk. Oily fish, particularly in non-smoked forms, are packed with omega-3 fatty acids, which are crucial for brain health and the development of a foetus's brain and eyes during pregnancy.

Therefore, it's important to maintain a balanced perspective on this issue, recognising the potential risks while not overlooking the nutritional benefits that these food sources can provide.

---

Conclusion

As we navigate this complex issue, it's essential that we stay informed, make mindful choices, and remember that moderation and variety are the keys to a balanced, healthy diet. While smoked fish may pose a risk for listeriosis, non-smoked oily fish remain a valuable part of our dietary needs, providing essential nutrients for our overall well-being.

Read the full report here.